Poetry and Air, Imagery and Earth

rocksWhat do you see in this photograph? Go to the bottom of the post for some background. (Credit: Courtesy Bill Atkinson)

[UPDATED 5/3 at bottom.] I’ve posted on the role of art in biological conservation and efforts to use cartoons to convey the ironies, inconsistencies and uncomfortable realities surrounding global warming. Now it’s time for poetry, and photography, dealing with the human-altered atmosphere and earth. I stumbled on a new collection of climate poems (and scientific statements), available as a pdf download online from the British Council, an international organization devoted to promoting British culture and ideas around the world. The group granted permission to reproduce a poem. You’ll find it below.

rocksMunjina stone, West Australia (Credit: Courtesy Bill Atkinson)

In that spirit, I thought I’d also post a little quasi-poem I wrote a few years ago for Bill Atkinson, an extraordinary man who was one of the founding software designers behind the first Macintosh computers and now, among other things, makes extraordinarily detailed digital photographs both of landscapes and what you might call mineral-scapes — the world revealed by slicing a stone.

My little essay accompanying this photograph was one of a collection of writings paired with Mr. Atkinson’s sliced-rock pictures in “Within the Stone,” a book from BrownTrout Publishers (I have no financial interest in sales of the book). They were written Rorschach-style, drawing impressions out of the exposed shapes and colors. What do you see in the rock at right? Here’s what I saw:

Perhaps we tamed fire. Perhaps fire tamed us. Certainly we are still seduced by that glowing dance of a thousand roseate veils, whether in the shimmering heat of the hearth or the growl of the V-8.

While water soothes and nourishes, fire empowers. The astonishing magic of controlled combustion, facilitated by Earth’s just-right atmosphere and ample stores of fuels, has allowed humans to transform from scattered gatherers into a gathering global force.

Fire transports us, and in return we transport fire. Together, for better and worse, we have made the world our own.

Next is a poem from the British Council book, “Feeling the Pressure: Poetry and science of climate change,” edited by Paul Munden.

The Forecast

‘What’s the weather in Normal?’ I asked Dad
every time I called home.
Hometown as axis and norm –
I liked the sound of it.

Every time I called home,
he’d relate, first, the usual stats.
I liked the sound of it,
the run of numbers: temp, precip, dew point.

He’d relate, first, the usual stats
and move on to weather patterns
derived from the run of numbers –
El Niño, La Niña, climate change.

Moving on to weather patterns,
he spent more and more time reading reports
about El Niño, La Niña, climate change,
and began to see to his daughters’ future.

Spending more and more time on reports,
hometown as axis and norm,
he began to see his daughters’ future.
What’s the weather in Normal? I don’t ask.

– Carrie Etter

“The Forecast,” by Carrie Etter — first published in “Feeling the Pressure,” edited by Paul Munden (British Council, 2008) — is copyright Carrie Etter 2008 and reprinted by permission of the publisher.

I’ve been told off and on that we’ll know society is really absorbing the idea that humans are influencing important Earth systems when the discussion spills out of the environmental niche and into the broader cultural discourse. Do you see signs this is happening?

P.S. The Bill Atkinson photograph opening this post is a cross-section through a sample of Dali stone (Dali referring not to the artist, but to a place in China’s Yunnan province where marble is quarried). I’ll post my little haiku giving my impressions of that image over the weekend. I’d love to hear yours. Give it a try. It feels a bit awkward, particularly for a reporter so used to using words in a straightforward way, but it’s fun in the end.

UPDATE, 5/3:
Here’s what I wrote to accompany the Dali stone image:


Humanity is etching its signature across its earthscape: diverting waterways, extracting essentials, transforming the air, scratching pathways. The advance is as inexorable, and natural, as that of rust on iron or microbes on a plate of agar. We till that which can be tilled, and therefore must be tilled, until our outward press meets sterile soils. But as we gain a global view, and regard our transformed sphere, we now ponder an unavoidable question: What next?

Comments are no longer being accepted.

Many floodplains around the world are silt-filled millponds developed by earlier generations of people who built their economies on water-power.

When the growing population deforested the hillsides to make mortar, cement, iron and eventually steam, the mud washed down and filled the millponds.

RE: “I’ve been told off and on that we’ll know society is really absorbing the idea that humans are influencing important Earth systems when the discussion spills out of the environmental niche and into the broader cultural discourse. Do you see signs this is happening?”

— Yes.

Hi Elliott-
Saw this and thought it might be of interest for a science class.
Jeff

a skeptic’s haiku:

warming?
cooling?
prognosticators get it wrong,
follow the money!

//www.foxnews.com/printer_friendly_story/0,3566,353844,00.html

A tiger skin rug—
sad relic of living past.
Earth trampled—life flayed.

Gerry Gomez Pearlberg
//globalswarminghoneybees.blogspot.com/

Nice work. The harmony of mother nature does not require any part of it to cease. Certain elitists like Al Gore believe there world would be a much better place without poor people. I disagree. Every human life is valuable. His agenda to cause mass starvation of the world’s poor in order to reduce their population is not only cruel but evil. We need to care for those less fortunate, not starve them so we can roam the world in private jets making deals with governments to exploit the poor.

Everything one does has consequence. Mr. Gore needs to realize that. It is basis science. An apparently positive act can have negative consequences. Unfortunately, many do not have the intelligence to realize this. They promote their agendas without thinking of other consequences. They avoid to debate and hold themselves out to be the inherently and morally right.

Mr. Revkin, your work is appreciated. There are several others who contribute to this paper who are unable to provide balance. There are still people who read the Times who have the ability to reason.

Let’s face it, because no one will: it all comes down to halting human population growth, then slowly shrinking it back to a level where other species have breathing room, and we have a smaller energy footprint on the earth. I see no sign of this discussion and how it could be, must be, done. Without this, our energy needs will continue to grow. No matter what “solutions” technology comes up with, human population growth will overwhelm them. What I’m suggesting is that the solution to climate change is not technical, but psychological.

I inherited from my father, a geologist, a sliced stone that looks exactly like a stretch of land edged by a line of ferny-leafed trees. I think it’s sandstone etched by small plant fossils. My strongest memory of my father is when he heard me practicing my grade school assignment to memorize “The Chambered Nautilus.”
“Do you know what that poem MEANS?” He asked. “No,” I answered. He went to his glass case, took out a sliced nautilus, showed me the expanding sections and explained. There were tears in his eyes before he fnished.

One of the first things I loved about the Google Earth program (back when it was launched as Keyhole) was the starkly beautiful images it revealed of the Earth’s surface, many in dizzying color. Images very much like the Bill Atkinson photograph you feature, only shot from many miles up in space.

Try exploring the Earth this way. The Australian outback, the Siberian tundra, Arabia’s Empty Quarter – we live on a work of art!

The post by Lyle Vos should not go unanswered as it contains terrible lies. Mr. Gore is speaking out about global warming in order to try to prevent the kinds of catastrophes, such as mass starvation, that could occur as the earth heats up. And in fact many of the food shortages we are starting to see, in Africa especially, are caused by the type of climate changes that Al Gore is speaking out about. Mr. Vos says that there are people who read the Times who have the ability to reason, but apparently he is not one of them.

The comment # 6 is just plain weird. Out of left field this strange attack on Gore. What’s the connection? And the bizarrely twisted idea that Gore hopes to eliminate poverty by starving poor people to death? Where did that come from? Of course I agree that everything has consequences – including the spreading of lies by this crazy person..

Anyway, Gore is a piker when it comes to real solutions. Now Bush, there’s the man for me. Look past his waffling attempts to placate the liberal press and see his real agenda. Eliminate the oil shortage by burning up all the oil as quickly as possible, Voila! No oil, no shortage. Ya can’t have a shortage of what don’t exist. Besides, with the globe thus sufficiently warmed, we won’t even need oil. We’ll be warm and toasty. Tropical fruits will grow everywhere and just fall out of the trees into our outstretched hands. And , oh yes, we’ll all be in perfect health because the weak and the sick will have succumbed to pollution before they’re out of childhood, leaving only the strong and fit to enjoy the earthlu paradise.

Marty

This post really hits home.

“We’ll know society is really absorbing the idea that humans are influencing important Earth systems when the discussion spills out of the environmental niche and into the broader cultural discourse. Do you see signs this is happening?”

In short, YES. I work with Blue Earth, a Seattle-based non-profit that helps documentary photographers bring their projects from vision to reality.

In the project submissions we have seen over the past few years, projects devoted to the effects of climate change (on people, wildlife, commerce, and communities) have featured heavily. Several current projects come to mind:

– Benjamin Drummond and Sara Steele’s “Facing Climate Change”
– Gary Braasch’s “World View of Global Warming”
– Camille Seaman’s “Siberia is Melting”
– Daniel Beltra’s “Forest at Risk”

Images from each project, and many others, can be seen at //www.blueearth.org.

Sleep tight sweet Aphrodite

Oh homo erectus …he wrecked us …
he wrecked us
So why did he leave us
small brain should have been a select us
Oh homo erectus …he wrecked us …
he wrecked us…
should have left that fire alone…
stuck with the raw …and left dark matter in the dark…
oh pine for homo erectus
when fight or flight didn’t need to check a manifest
and destiny was timeless

but hush

Sleep tight sweet Aphrodite
the post human era will be even better than before!
for nature will nurture even more
except for the odd meteorite
The biggest sound won’t be a bite
though that may seem a little trite
for finite is just time that said good night

Elizabeth Tjader May 2, 2008 · 12:45 pm

Elizabeth Tjader comments:

Wow, I’ve never, ever gotten the impression Mr. Gore thinks this planet would be a better place without poor people. I’ve certainly gotten that distinct impression from the Bush/Cheney administration though.

Andy, the photo’s and your prose/poetry are beautiful. The Earth is filled with magical discoveries such as the above posted photographs. One of my favorite pieces of Earth art is lichen and moss embedded in stone, on tree trunks or old rock walls. Just yesterday I picked some tinsel Spanish tree moss from my Hackberry tree to create a bed on which to bury my deceased kitty. I was the reminded of the Native Americans who used varieties of moss for diapers and/or to soothe rashes. Long gone are those resourceful, bountiful earth friendly days.
There are beautiful pictures of Earth’s most intimate discoveries still around, though I fear their disappearance as time marches on. I hope I’m wrong.
These photo’s are lovely. The Australian slice reminds of the slot canyons of the Southwest.
Elizabeth Tjader

David B. Benson May 2, 2008 · 1:13 pm

Lyle Vos (6) wrote “Certain elitists like Al Gore believe there world would be a much better place without poor people.” Quit MSU (Making Stuff Up).

British poets aren’t the only ones who have been writing about global warming, unsurprisingly. Prominent American poets W.S. Merwin, Robert Haas, and Jane Hirschfield have also touched on global warming, and Hirschfield’s “pebble” on the subject (which unfortunately I can’t find at this moment) is quoted by James Hansen in some of his lectures.

Of course, what’s interesting about poetry is its ability to see beyond the obvious. This poem from Charles Simic, our poet laureate, is (I think) about the issues raised by climate change, psychological and otherwise. But some might disagree. Judge for yourself.

//achangeinthewind.typepad.com/achangeinthewind/2008/04/the-storm-we-ca.html

My comment which includes a refernce to Al Gore is not out of thin air. I suggest you read Al Gore’s work and speeches. He has been a proponent of limiting the population of poor people. He has gone as far as promoting abortion in poor countries. When I write “promoting”, I am distinguishing this from permitting.

The rest of the world is developing and seeking to have a standard of living and quality of life that Americans take for granted. They are demanding more and better quality food and the ability to travel at will. This is creating a huge demand on natural resources. However, Gore’s policy is to limit the growth of these populations and make it the cost of these resources out of their reach. That is not a solution. It is not fair to keep others down simply so that he and other wealthy Americans can continue to live our great lifestyles. We are not alone on this planet. One needs to travel the world to see how the other 90 percent live.

Al Gore and I have different goals. My efforts are to increase the health and wealth of the world’s population – not just the priviliged few.

When decisions are made, one must think about the ramifications. The move to ethanol based fuels so quickly has been devestating to the poor. Many, like myself, argued for a transition. However, the hype by Gore and others and the lobbying of the corporate farmers led the government to oversubsidize ethanol. It was a mistake. I am not against ethanol, but adoption should have transitioned at a slower pace. Those of us who knew about ethanol production with current technology knew it was going to produce server problems in the food and energy markets.

born in ancient sea
nature’s history
fireplace in LA

Jeremy Abramowitz May 2, 2008 · 3:23 pm

sas:

“follow the money”

You mean like how all the so-called skeptics are funded by oil interests?

Evidently some people confuse limiting a number of something with limiting the rate of growth of the number of something. (Perhaps they didn’t learn calculus in school.) It is obvious that every individual person will be poorer if a finite quantity of riches are distributed equally among a greater number of people.

re: #19 j abramowitz

jeremy,
the amount of skeptics’ funding from oil companies is a tired nostrum; the big money is to be made from the trillions to be siphoned from cap and trade offsets, carbon taxes to be collected, academic “research” grants to co2 warriors, etc. not to mention al gore’s recently closed (filled!) $680 million green fund. i’m still waiting for my check from the oil companies. why don’t you read the link before firing.

//www.foxnews.com/printer_friendly_story/0,3566,353844,00.html

Laurie Dougherty May 2, 2008 · 4:51 pm

A haiku, based not on a first impression of the image, but after looking up Dali stone and finding that marble is a form of calcium carbonate:

carbon into stone
the work of eons; carbon
into air so swift

17 (Vos):

He has been a proponent of limiting the population of poor people. He has gone as far as promoting abortion in poor countries. When I write “promoting”, I am distinguishing this from permitting.

I call bullpucky. Show your evidence.

I also note how quickly the “Algore is fat!” rhetoric must come out. Why do the FUD purveyors feel as if they must spam comment threads?

Better denialist rhetoriticians, please.

And when can we get [killfile] activated on Greasemonkey to spray this fever swamp?

Best,

Ð

Art Fights for Beauty;

and that can help keep us sane!

Let’s appreciate …

There was a picture in an article just the other day of America all lit up at night.
It reminded me of Heaven on Earth. But it is not benign and perhaps that should be the goal, to make it benign.
It is an awesome accomplishment, this transition from the darkness, these streams of traffic with ruby and diamond lights streaming through the hills of Southern California, these towering buildings and masses of fine houses.
But it is not benign and perhaps that should be the goal, to make it benign.
But then there was a picture of the forests in Alaska that were but standing dead trees, the destruction caused by bark beetles because global warming had failed to freeze the larva. This might be considered to be a good photographer’s choice to capture, this grand episode of the power of vanity to have its ramifications seen far off where few would otherwise see.
And the blue and the darkness of the ocean with the sun and the moon projecting a line of light on the water that we all think is there but that is not really there. And then we see an article that says inside this ocean there is little life because the life that would otherwise be there is suffocated by our vanity because we might not have realized that all we have is not just benign.
And we wonder about our “leaders” and why they also are vain.
So something is missing if we are to make it benign.
I like the patterns in wood and from dead wood after it has weathered some more. Nice colors with some oil as a finish.